No banned books yet, just urge to 'evolve'

Thursday, April 26, 2018
Steve Jordahl (

Nazi book burningCalifornia lawmakers are fast-tracking a bill that bans counselors from helping adults with unwanted same-sex attraction but there is growing evidence the legislation is more much ominous.

Assembly Bill 2943, which has passed in the State Assembly, is now in the California State Senate.

If passed and signed into law, the bill would ban "advertising and any tangible goods or services for personal, family, or household use, offering or engaging in sexual orientation change efforts with an individual."

In other words, if a good such a book or a service, such as a Christian conference, claim to help someone with unwanted same-sex attraction, those goods and services would be illegal in California.

"This legislation is so broad," warns Pacific Justice Institute attorney Brad Dacus, "it would ban books - actually ban books - in the United States of America."

Dacus, Brad (PJI)Such claims are predictably being dismissed or ignored by the bill's supporters as right-wing fearmongering.

Homosexual-rights group Human Rights Campaign trumpeted the bill in an April 19 press release because it declares so-called "conversion therapy" a fraudulent practice and bans the practice in the state for adults. A law already on the books bans "conversion therapy" for children.  

Yet the HRC press release failed to address concerns raised by conservatives.

A lengthy Media Matters story from April 2 lists the "anti-LGBTQ groups" fighting the legislation but also fails to address their concerns.

Explaining why conservatives are right to be alarmed, attorney-writer David French explains in a National Review story that the bill's own language states that goods and services are deemed unlawful, and so "goods" include books and "services" include a bookstore that sells it.

David French tweet (CA bill)French goes on to point out that the bill's language defines "sexual orientation change efforts" as fraudulent to the State of California, and others are pointing out the biblical belief that homosexuality is sinful yet salvation can change that person from homosexual to straight.  

"This is a dramatic infringement on First Amendment rights," warns French, "rendered even more pernicious by its functional declaration of certain kinds of religious speech and argument as the equivalent of consumer fraud."

French's warning was buoyed by video of a California lawmaker, Al Muratsuch, suggesting during debate that the Church must "evolve with the times."  

"It looks like the State Senate is going to likely pass this," Dacus predicts. "And then it will go to the governor's desk and it will be up to Governor Jerry Brown to decide whether or not he chooses to respect the Constitution's First Amendment right of religious freedom."

Asked about the bill on American Family Radio, longtime conservative activist Gary Bauer said the Left has run the board in California, where it controls the legislature and the governor's office, and dominates Silicon Valley and Hollywood.

"And what they're building in California," he said, "looks more like Venezuela than it does the United States of America."


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details





After two days of testimony in the impeachment inquiry, I am …





Iran supreme leader warns ‘thugs’ amid gas price protests
US, S Korea postpone joint exercise criticized by N Korea
White House urgently ramps up push for drug cost legislation
Democrat Edwards reelected governor of Louisiana
Alleged gunman, victim among 6 charged after game shooting
Parents, 3 sons die in apparent murder-suicide in San Diego
American held in Turkey as IS suspect returns to US
Sandy Hook lawsuit could force Remington to open books


Hong Kong police officer shot with arrow, protesters set fires as Chinese troops appear to clean streets
Elise Stefanik emerges as main Schiff antagonist in fiery impeachment hearings
Nearly 80,000 immigrants approved for DACA have arrest records, USCIS report finds
Study confirms media coverage of Trump is 'more hostile than normal' and ignores good economic news
White House budget official questioned in impeachment probe


Cartoon of the Day
Russia investigation wraps up but Dems keep digging

"Rocky" RussiansA U.S. House panel investigating Russian meddling in U.S. elections has released its final report and wrapped up its business – sort of.