ColoradoCare a costly cure, says critic

Wednesday, June 29, 2016
Chris Woodward (

stethoscope and cashColoradans continue to debate single-payer healthcare ahead of a ballot initiative this November.

The ballot initiative is known as Amendment 69 and creates something called ColoradoCare. Supporters of the effort are quoted as saying everything from "it is going to make a huge difference in people's lives" – to "this shows you the power and strength of when people come together." Some critics, meanwhile, say this creates a "Communist healthcare system," while others believe it ranks among the worst ideas ever in government.

Hadley Heath Manning of Independent Women's Voice lives in Colorado. She's definitely not fond of the idea, citing free market and cost concerns.

"This would result in a very high increase in our taxes and about a $25 billion a year increase in our state spending," says Manning. "Now, you have to take this with a grain of salt, because just about every government healthcare program has gone over budget in reality compared to the cost projections."

Manning adds that employers are going to be faced with a payroll tax increase of 6.67 percent, and workers themselves will pay the other 3.33 percent, making it a 10-percent increase in payroll taxes.

"This would give Colorado the highest payroll and income tax of any state in the country," she continues. "There is certainly a concern that there will be an in-migration of people who want to take advantage of the benefits of this kind of program; and also an out-migration of people in the state of Colorado, who do want to do business here, who have an entrepreneurial spirit, who have many workers on their payroll because this kind of tax increase simply won't be one that's easy to bear."

Incidentally, ColoradoCare is permitted under ObamaCare.


"The Affordable Care Act (ACA) or ObamaCare has a section which allows states to apply for a waiver from some of the law's requirements – and the way that a state can get one of these waivers is essentially by coming up with its own plan," explains Manning. "States have to ensure that they're going to cover just as many people as the ACA would cover and that people who are covered have the same level of benefit coverage as they would have had under the ACA."

The website says people would save big with ColoradoCare, while having better quality care under a plan that aims to cover everyone in Colorado. Supporters of ObamaCare have made similar claims over the years – claims that have been brought up every time there is a news report of higher premiums, taxes, and problems in Obamacare.

"What's ironic is, one state has already tried something very similar to what Coloradans have the opportunity to do this fall," says Manning. "Vermont actually passed a single-payer healthcare program at the state level, but ultimately abandoned the proposal when they found that this was going to be bad for economic growth in their state, that the costs were actually going to heavily outweigh the benefits and it wasn't going to be feasible from a financial perspective. So I think that Coloradans should actually be paying attention to what's already taken place in Vermont."


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details





What's the most likely result if Democrats' plan for impeachment fails?





US and Turkey have friendly talks but differences persist
As rockets rain down, Israel intensifies its strikes in Gaza
Overdoses possible in some student deaths on USC campus
Bishop who investigated sex abuse accused of sex abuse
Astros' Verlander, Mets' deGrom win 2nd Cy Young Awards
Democrats' key witness grilled about Trump’s hold on Ukraine aid
Arctic blast spreads shivers from Maine to Deep South


Trump vows new Ukraine transcript release in post-impeachment hearing press conference
Republicans denounce 'hearsay' testimony on first day of Trump impeachment hearings
Disney Plus streaming platform includes trigger warnings for 'Pinocchio,' 'Lady and the Tramp,' and more. The warning is for 'outdated cultural depictions.'
Kellogg partnered with LGBTQ group for 'All Together' cereal, but consumers weren't happy
Hillary Clinton says 'many, many, many people' want her to join 2020 Democratic primary


Cartoon of the Day
ObamaCare - not GOP's alternative - is a 'big mess'

electronic health records EHRWhen it comes to repealing and replacing ObamaCare, some people believe it won't be easy - but Republicans argue there's no other choice.