Attorney: 'Setback' ruling really a federalism issue

Wednesday, November 28, 2018
 | 
Chris Woodward (OneNewsNow.com)

gavel with U.S. flagAn attorney is applauding a federal ruling that appears, at first glance, to shrug off the brutal practice of female genital mutilation.

(Caution: this story contains content that some may find objectionable)

A federal judge in Michigan ruled last week that a federal law protecting girls from genital mutilation is unconstitutional, a case brought about after several doctors carried out the procedure in Michigan.

FGM is a religious custom performed by Dawoodi Bohra, a Muslim sect that included Dr. Jumana Nagarwala and other Detroit-area defendants who are accused of mutilating 100 girls over 12 years.

Women's rights's groups described the ruling as a "setback" for girls' protections, and the U.S. Attorney's Office also denounced the ruling. 

U.S. District Judge Bernard Friedman called the practice "despicable" but ruled that Congress has no authority to enact such a law, Fox News reported. 

"I wish we had more federal judges who are willing to rein back the authority of the federal government," responds attorney Rob Muise of the American Freedom Law Center.

woman wearing burqa (burka)"The court didn't find that there was some sort of right of Muslims to engage in female genital mutilation," Muise explains. "What [Friedman] did find was that Congress didn't have the right to prohibit it as a matter of criminal law without there being some basis in the Constitution for the authority to do so."

Michigan has an anti-FGM law that includes a 15-year maximum sentence, Muise points out, while the federal law is only a five-year maximum.

According to The Associated Press, only about half the states have laws prohibiting female genital mutilation. 

"This should be a notice to all states," Muise tells OneNewsNow, "that you need to pass state laws that prohibit this sort of conduct."

The doctor and other defendants are still facing federal charges of conspiracy and obstruction. 

Comments

We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details

FEATURED PODCAST

SIGN UP FOR OUR DAILY NEWSBRIEF

SUBSCRIBE

VOTE IN OUR POLL

After two days of testimony in the impeachment inquiry, I am …

CAST YOUR VOTE

GET PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

SUBSCRIBE

LATEST AP HEADLINES

Democrats invite Trump to testify in impeachment inquiry
Iran’s top leader warns ‘thugs’ as protests reach 100 cities
Hong Kong police storm university held by protesters
US, S Korea postpone joint exercise criticized by N Korea
White House urgently ramps up push for drug cost legislation
Democrat Edwards reelected governor of Louisiana

LATEST FROM THE WEB

Democrats' smear campaign against Trump sparked White House involvement in Ukraine, Devin Nunes says
Rep. Jim Jordan: Still no quid pro quo
Leaked focus group results reveal Democrats' impeachment messaging plans, weak legal case
Hong Kong police officer shot with arrow, protesters set fires as Chinese troops appear to clean streets
Elise Stefanik emerges as main Schiff antagonist in fiery impeachment hearings

CARTOON OF THE DAY

Cartoon of the Day
NEXT STORY
A preemptive step to avoid fines, possible jail time

Brush & Nib (artists)Two Christian business owners in Phoenix are hoping their legal challenge to a local ordinance will usher in a happy new year for them.