Boston discriminates against Christian flag

Monday, September 10, 2018
Chris Woodward (

Christian flagAn attorney is labeling as "preposterous" a federal ruling that allows the city of Boston to deny requests to fly a Christian flag.

An organization known as Camp Constitution wanted to fly a Christian flag on a pole that Boston uses to fly various flags – alongside poles flying the U.S. and Massachusetts state flags.

United States District Court Judge Denise Casper said that the city's policy against flying non-secular flags is reasonable, based on the city of Boston's interest in avoiding the appearance of endorsing a particular religion – and a consequential violation of the Establishment Clause.

"As the City has done in the past, it will allow Plaintiffs to hold an event on City Hall Plaza," Casper declared in his remarks that were published by The Boston Globe. "It will also give Plaintiffs the opportunity to . . . display the Christian flag while on City Hall Plaza."

But this was not the case on the flagpole.

"This case is of personal interest to me for a variety of reasons – one of which is [that] I used to work in a building right there on City Hall Plaza, and so I would see out [of] my window every day the three flag poles that are in question here," Massachusetts Family Institute President Andrew Beckwith shared. "One was the U.S. flag, the second one was the state flag and the third was sort of originally the city flag, but almost literally every day, there was another flag going up that flagpole, and we actually sort of had a little game in the office where we'd try to figure out what the flag, what country or organization the flag represented."

Some of those flags were from other nations whose symbols, included crosses. The Christian flag includes a cross in the upper left corner.

"I know there were certainly flags that had the Islamic crescent moon on them as part of the national flag," Beckwith continued. "The LGBT rainbow flag was flown pretty regularly, the transgender flag has been flown on that flagpole, and those express very clear worldviews, which frankly, are being pursued with as much vigor as a religion in many cases."

Regardless, the pro-family leader maintained that one cannot take what is effectively a public forum – "which is what they've made that city flagpole into" – and then restrict it to not include certain flags or certain speech because it is religious in nature.

"You cannot – under the First Amendment – discriminate against faith groups because they're a faith group," Beckwith explained. "It is ironic that in the city of Boston itself, which has such a deep history for our nation, there are Christian and religious symbols – engravings literally carved into the stone of the statehouse and on Boston Common – just a block away from city hall, so to say that we somehow can't have a flag that represents and is consistent with that Christian heritage in the city is pretty preposterous."


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




What do you think of some Democrats' proposal to do away with U.S. Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE)?





Hong Kong’s divide: 1 protest for democracy, 1 for China
Signs of recession worry Trump ahead of 2020
Kim expresses 'great satisfaction' over NKorea weapons tests
Google employees call for pledge not to work with ICE
Arrests precede major demonstrations in Portland, Oregon
Medical examiner rules Epstein death a suicide by hanging
Palestinian killed after attack on Israeli teens


Opinion - Matthew Brodsky: Tlaib, Omar don’t deserve sympathy for being barred from Israel – They deserve condemnation
Joe Biden confuses Burlington, Iowa, with Burlington, Vt., in latest gaffe
2 Missouri law enforcement officers 'ambushed' while serving eviction notice; suspect in custody
Trump Renaissance vs. Democrat Dark Ages
Buttigieg offers most controversial statement yet on campaign trail: Get rid of the DH


Cartoon of the Day
Atheist groups fight to keep God out of schools

no crossAtheist groups are continuing their barrage on the public school system.