Counselor, employer strongly disagree over claims of religious discrimination

Friday, May 25, 2018
Chris Woodward (

counseling therapy session"Be a social worker first, and a Catholic second." That's what a therapist claims she was told just before she was fired. Now she's taking her former employer to court.

Kathleen Lorentzen worked at HealthSource Saginaw where she provided a range of psychological counseling.

"She had an outstanding work record, with no complaints about her job whatsoever," says attorney Tyler Brooks of Thomas More Law Center, the organization representing Lorentzen. "In the summer of 2017, she had a gay couple referred to her for marriage counseling and decided that this was inconsistent with her sincerely held religious beliefs." Lorentzen, says Brooks, is a devout Catholic.

When Lorentzen went to her supervisor to ask that another therapist do the counseling, Lorentzen claims her supervisor became angry but later agreed to the change and directed Lorentzen to write a letter to that effect – which she did.

"She kind of thought that this was taken care of until she was called into a second meeting with that same supervisor and another supervisor from HealthSource where they then interrogated her about her religious beliefs," Brooks continues.

gavel with Bible 1"When she tried to explain her beliefs and talk about the teachings of the Catholic Church on marriage, she was told by one of the men that she needed to be a social worker first and a Catholic second."

Not long after, Lorentzen received a letter in the mail saying she was being terminated in 30 days. The TMLC attorney explains harassment followed.

"After she was told she was being terminated, she was subjected to some pretty odd but very intimidating forms of harassment by one of these men in particular who decided he would become very physically intimidating towards Lorentzen," says Brooks.

"In one incident in particular, she was at a work station and he came up and sort of stood very close beside her and pushed into her in a way that she felt very uncomfortable with –  and she could feel his body pressed against her. And it was so odd that the receptionist saw this and, once the supervisor left, asked Lorentzen: What's going on here? because the office had become so inhospitable towards Lorentzen."

The complaint was filed in federal court alleging discrimination under both federal and Michigan state law.

OneNewsNow contacted Plunkett Cooney law firm, the organization representing HealthSource Saginaw, and was provided the following response:

"HealthSource Saginaw steadfastly denies Ms. Lorentzen's fundamentally false allegations and is extremely disheartened by her choice to knowingly publish a work of fiction disguised as a legal pleading. Due to the fact that litigation is pending neither I nor HealthSource Saginaw will issue any public comment beyond this: HealthSource Saginaw is committed to prohibiting all forms of illegal discrimination and retaliation on its premises. It would not tolerate nor engage in acts similar to what Ms. Lorentzen has fabricated in her 21-page complaint. Ms. Lorentzen has mischaracterized the nature of her relationship with HealthSource Saginaw, provided false information about what occurred prior to the end of that relationship, and omitted several key facts as it relates to her particular actions and representations. We look forward to very aggressively defending this case and are confident that the judicial process will bring the truth to light and result in a judgment in Defendants' favor."

Consider Supporting Us?

The staff at strives daily to bring you news from a biblical perspective. If you benefit from this platform and want others to know about it please consider a generous gift today.



We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




I agree with this HHS proposal reversing the Obamacare section benefiting transgenders primarily because …





Bolton says N. Korea missile tests violated UN resolutions
‘Revolution’ in Poland as nation confronts priestly abuse
'Here we go again': Judge blocks Mississippi abortion ban
US beefing up forces in Middle East to counter Iran
Wisconsin man who kidnapped Jayme Closs gets life in prison
Authorities raid 247 Colorado homes growing black market pot
Lawsuit: Flood damage at Noah's Ark attraction in Kentucky
Missouri governor signs bill banning abortions at 8 weeks


Trump arrives in Japan, kicking off 4-day state visit with trade talks at its center
CAIR says 'Aladdin' film will worsen Islamophobia and racism because it's being released under President Trump
GOP conservative temporarily blocks $19B disaster bill
Katie Pavlich defends Trump for defending himself, calls out MSNBC's Scarborough
Democrat Adam Schiff calls declassification order 'un-American' — and gets torched by his own words


Cartoon of the Day
Christian baker to be baked or vindicated by SCOTUS?

Jack Phillips making cakeThe United States Supreme Court (SCOTUS) will soon issue its ruling on the Masterpiece Cakeshop lawsuit, and justices will decide a very fundamental question.