Fired fire chief, First Amendment get their day in court

Wednesday, October 14, 2015
Charlie Butts (

Kelvin Cochran press conference 620x300A former Atlanta fire chief is in court today fighting for his job and defending his First Amendment right to free speech. 

Kelvin Cochran, fired from his job last year after he wrote a self-published book about marriage and sexuality, is suing the City of Atlanta and its mayor, Kasim Reed, in federal court.

An attorney representing Kelvin Cochran, the fired Atlanta fire chief, says a federal judge seemed to understand the constitutional issues at hand.

Alliance Defending Freedom attorney Kevin Theriot was among the legal team that represented Cochran on Wednesday in a federal court hearing.

Theriot, Kevin (ADF)The hearing was held after the City of Atlanta and Mayor Kasim Reed filed a motion to dismiss Cochran's lawsuit. ADF filed a motion in response, which the judge will now review. That decision could take up to two months.

Theriot tells OneNewsNow that attorneys for the city claimed that Cochran is free to believe as he wishes.

"He just has to keep them at his home, keep them at his church, keep them in his own little Bible study - completely contrary to the First Amendment," the attorney says of his client.  

Theriot says attorneys for the city "essentially conceded" during the hearing that it's too early to dismiss Cochran's case unless the court finds that his beliefs about marriage and sex are a concern to the public.

ADF reports it's optimistic the case will go to trial unless the City of Atlanta decides to settle the case. 

Alliance Defending Freedom attorney Jeremy Tedesco tells OneNewsNow that Mayor Reed originally suspended Cochran because he was "deeply disturbed" by the book. Reed has since given other reasons for Cochran's firing, the attorney alleges. 

"Those are what we call pretexts in the law," Tedesco explains, "things that you say to try and cover up the wrong things that you did. And that's what the city is doing here."

The case goes to trial today, beginning with a motion to dismiss filed by Reed. 

Cochran's lawsuit alleges that Reed and the city fired Cochran "solely because he holds religious beliefs concerning same-sex marriage and homosexual conduct," views that are contrary to views held by Reed and the City of Atlanta.

Reed's lawsuit can be read here. The motion to dismiss can be read here

Cochran wrote "Who Told You That you Were Naked" after he and fellow church members discussed Adam's sin at a men's Bible study.

The book includes discussion of homosexuality - in a city with an "LGBT advisor" to Mayor Reed and a "LGBT Liason Unit" in the police department. 

gavel with U.S. flagAccording to Reed's motion to dismiss, some copies of the book were handed out to city employees and a city council member, Alex Wan, learned of its contents. The city's "upper management" was contacted, including human resources, and four days later Cochran was suspended. 

After the fire chief was terminated, Wan said Cochran's firing "sends a strong message to employees about how much we value diversity and how we adhere to a non-discriminatory environment." 

USA Today identified Wan as Atlanta's only openly homosexual council member. 

Cochran says his constitutional rights are on the line.

"All Americans are guaranteed the freedom of actually believing and thinking in such a way that does not cost them consequences that I've experienced in this termination," he says.

Editor's note: This story has been updated to reflect results of the Oct. 14 court hearing. 


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details





Your reaction to the positive job numbers released on Friday?





Biden formally clinches Democratic presidential nomination
Facebook removes nearly 200 accounts tied to hate groups
Barr says he didn’t give tactical order to clear protesters
Citing jobs, Trump claims victory over virus, econ collapse
Black cops feel pain of Floyd's death, duty to their uniform


Pete Hegseth blasts DC mayor, says National Guard prevented desecration of monuments
Jeff Sessions shuts down Ilhan Omar in Twitter spat, then asks: 'How's your brother, by the way?'
California Gov. Newsom wants to set use-of-force standard
Drew Brees sends a message to President Trump about his comments on kneeling protests
Maxine Waters freaks out: Remove Trump 'before this would-be dictator takes us all down'


Cartoon of the Day
A New Jersey lesbian defends a Christian in Kentucky

Westboro protesterThe owner of a Kentucky t-shirt printing business is still unsure of his legal rights while a "human rights" commission is appealing its loss in court.