Infringing on gun rights just the beginning, says analyst

Friday, January 24, 2020
Chris Woodward (

Second Amendment (gun + flag)A policy analyst with The Heritage Foundation says "red flag" laws, if not written well, tend to violate people's fundamental rights under the U.S. Constitution – which is why she has a problem with what's happening in the Virginia legislature.

The Virginia Senate has passed legislation calling for a red flag law, but not everyone is on board with the legislation. Supporters of red flag laws say they're meant to disarm individuals who are believed to be dangerous or are showing they're a danger to themselves or others.

Amy Swearer is senior legal policy analyst with The Heritage Foundation, a center-right think tank in Washington, DC. She says there's nothing wrong with that mindset – but the problem with these types of laws, she argues, is that they lend themselves to due process violations if they're not written well.

"So, here what you see is that there's very low burdens of proof," Swearer begins. "That means it's very, very easy to sort of take guns first and ask questions later, which is not something that we should be doing when we're talking about restricting fundamental rights like the right to keep and bear arms."

Swearer hopes the Virginia House of Delegates will make "good improvements" to the legislation, sending it back to the Senate.


"It seems right now that the bill that came out of the Senate, again, just has some problematic language that … makes it very, very easy to take guns first without actually giving that person a hearing before taking those guns," she offers.

Virginia would not be the only state with a red flag law. Similar statutes can be found in other parts of the country. Swearer also sees problems in those laws.

"Even if you're not a gun owner and you don't necessarily care about the rights of gun owners, it's important that you pay attention to these situations. Because any time that we start making it acceptable for the government to … ignore due process for any fundamental right – whether it's the Second Amendment, the First Amendment, the Fourth Amendment – it becomes that much easier for government to say, 'Well, you know, we sort of infringed on those rights in other places, and so we can do it here too,'" Sweater explains.

"So, it's important that we make sure that all of our fundamental constitutional rights are protected at an equal level so that we don't have to keep playing this game and having this battle every single time the government wants to infringe on one right or the other."


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details





Your reaction to the positive job numbers released on Friday?





Citing jobs, Trump claims victory over virus, econ collapse
Black cops feel pain of Floyd's death, duty to their uniform
Mail ballots from Tuesday's election push Biden over the top
Black Lives Matter rallies start in Australia amid court ban
Goodell says NFL was wrong for not listening to players
Unemployment rate falls to 13.3%, US adds 2.5 million jobs
Detained US Navy veteran freed by Iran as part of deal


Drew Brees sends a message to President Trump about his comments on kneeling protests
Maxine Waters freaks out: Remove Trump 'before this would-be dictator takes us all down'
Trump hits PBS' Yamiche Alcindor for asking how '.1 percent' increase in black unemployment is a 'victory'
4 reasons the 'collective culpability' racket is dangerous
The black and white of 'systemic racism'


Cartoon of the Day
Ministry has sad but necessary job: Protect children from adults

children praying in churchChild sexual abuse scandals have rocked the Catholic Church, the Boy Scouts, and far too many Protestant churches, which is why a ministry is working to protect children from becoming the next victim.