Liberal Methodist caucus rips IRD for call to follow biblical sexuality

Tuesday, January 7, 2020
Michael F. Haverluck (

Homosexual dude Methodist weddingA caucus within the United Methodist Church (UMC) was called out recently for condemning a Christian ministry that urged the mainline denomination to take a stand for biblical sexuality instead of promoting the far-left's pro-LGBTQ agenda.

Last week, Institute on Religion & Democracy (IRD) president Mark Tooley pointed out that a pro-homosexual faction within the UMC attacked his ministry for defending God's teaching on sexual morality.

Tooley, Mark (IRD)"This morning a liberal Methodist caucus emailed their year-end fundraiser by highlighting the threat from IRD – they even attached the full text of my own fundraiser from November!" Tooley wrote in his ministry email last Tuesday. "They call IRD 'reactionary' and 'harmful.' Well, their message speaks for itself."

Church attacks ministry for defending the Bible?

Tooley pulled the main quote from his ministry to which the liberal UMC caucus objected.

"IRD stands up for the truth of historic Christian teachings based on the Bible," the IRD quote condemned by Mainstream UMC reads. "We believe churches should proclaim the Gospel – not a far-left political agenda replacing the Kingdom of God with Big Government or the Sexual Revolution or anything else."

Mainstream UMC executive director Rev. Mark Holland emailed church members, calling IRD "the most far-right, far-out-there group in the Church," telling them that IRD is harmful to society for promoting biblical sexuality and supporting his denomination's "harmful" Traditional Plan that took effect New Year's Day.

"Clearly the most strident of the anti-gay coalition, Mr. Tooley claims among other things that 'IRD is the only group in America devoted exclusively to Church reform and accountability,'" Holland wrote in a Mainstream UMC email last Monday. "He is 'honored' at being labeled 'dangerous.' Indeed, they are the Breitbart News of the Church.'"

Holland was referring to the following statement Tooley made in November about churches dropping their Bibles as their source for doctrine and picking up the progressive playbook for their new teaching philosophy:

"I'm honored we are seen as 'dangerous' and 'exceptionally skilled' by activists who think the churches should be a liberal playground for their political activism."

But Holland urged Methodists to rally behind the LGBTQ community and activists to forward the homosexual agenda.

"Mainstream UMC [must] counter the IRD's reactionary, harmful rhetoric and actions, [as] we are committed to ending the harm to LGBTQ persons and their allies," Holland declared. "We are committed to balancing the narrative in the church, [and] together we can change to a regional structure in our church that allows the U.S. and Western Europe to move faithfully forward."

Tooley shot back at Holland, unapologetically asserting that churches should be in the business of championing God's Word – not opposing it while promoting progressives' social gospel.

"We contend for churches behaving not as lobbyists for trendy causes, but as churches proclaiming the Gospel, which America and every society so desperately need," the conservative evangelical leader impressed. "Some think it's 'reactionary' to uphold ancient truths, but it's captivity to trendy causes – not fidelity to Christian orthodoxy – which kills churches."

Tooley contended late last year that liberal teachings such as those coming out of the Episcopal and Lutheran churches used to be the only denominational doctrines that embraced LGBTQ activism and other progressive causes, but he warned that such philosophies have crept into churches that have typically held traditional biblical views.

"So much has changed over the past quarter century, but the liberalism that once was mostly confined to mainline Protestantism has now metastasized throughout American Christianity – including into many evangelical churches," Tooley pointed out in November.


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details





Do you feel restrictions on the size of gatherings are being unfairly applied to churches?





Trump tempers officials' grave assessments with optimism
  Debate heats up over using an anti-malaria drug for COVID-19
Stocks rise sharply on hopes of progress in battling virus
Tiger at NYC's Bronx Zoo tests positive for coronavirus
Justices rule for federal employee over age discrimination


Welcome to the police state: Police give woman $200 ticket for going for a drive amid stay-at-home order
COVID-19 and the politics of fear and panic
Med prof: There are ‘major problems’ with current coronavirus mortality estimates
US forced into unthinkable gamble with livelihoods
Sheriff rebels against governor: 'We will not be setting up a police state'


Cartoon of the Day
Is the liberal UMC 'takeover' cheating traditionalists?

UMC Book of Discipline (2016) 2Liberals in the United Methodist Church have masterminded a proposal to resolve the theological debate that has consumed their denomination for decades. But a lifelong member of the denomination argues that their "rigged" resolution is anything but equitable for traditionalists.