Another ObamaCare exit = fewer options = bad for consumers

Friday, May 12, 2017
Chris Woodward (

EXIT sign (green)Lawmakers need to pay attention to Aetna's latest decision involving ObamaCare. That's the advice of a senior health policy analyst with the Independent Women's Forum.

Aetna, the nation's third-largest health insurer, says it won't participate in ObamaCare exchanges in Nebraska and Delaware next year. The insurer had pulled out of several other states after losing nearly a half-billion dollars in 2016; this decision comes after projecting a $200 million loss this year.

Hadley Heath Manning of the Independent Women's Forum points out Aetna has been reducing its participation in state-based exchanges – and not just because of financial losses.

"They announced a while ago they wouldn't participate in Virginia's exchange, and that time they cited some of their concerns related to the current legislation under consideration that just passed the House," says Manning, IWF's director of health policy. "And of course this puts insurance companies in a difficult position because they're going to have to reconsider how they do business and what kind of plans they can offer depending on a variety of decisions that lawmakers at the federal and state level are making."

That said, when Aetna announced this week it would no longer participate in any of the exchanges, it didn't cite uncertainty related to the law, but rather financial losses the company has experienced.


"If an insurance carrier can't make money in the exchanges, then it's not in their best interest to participate," Manning adds. "We have to recognize that reality if we want to consider the best laws that are going to give consumers the most options and at the best prices."

Other insurers have said as much in recent months. Some have also been fleeing exchanges, including Humana, UnitedHealth, and even Blue Cross Blue Shield in some cases.

Over the two years, Aetna wanted to merge with Humana – and Anthem sought to merge with Cigna. Both those mergers were blocked by federal judges. OneNewsNow asked Manning if things would be different today had one or more merger been approved.

"The companies who suffered the financial losses were looking at mergers as a potential way to ward off some of their financial problems, and some people speculated that Aetna pulled out of some of the exchanges earlier as sort of revenge against the Obama administration for denying their merger request," answers Manning.

Aetna insurance"I don't know that that's so much the case because when you're a customer, whether we have the big five or the big three or a handful of options," she continues. "It really depends on where you live and what's available to you – and when you have consolidation in the health insurance market, that's another way that consumers face fewer options."

So whether it's insurers exiting the exchanges altogether or merging with other big insurance companies, the bottom line for consumers is the trend toward fewer choices.

"And fewer choices means not only do we have fewer options in terms of plans, but our networks depend on what plans we get, our doctors are dependent on those networks, and for us it's about accessing care and the prices that we pay," Manning concludes. "The trend has been bad for consumers regardless of what would have happened with those mergers."

Consider Supporting Us?

The staff at strives daily to bring you news from a biblical perspective. If you benefit from this platform and want others to know about it please consider a generous gift today.



We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




What's your reaction when you hear the term 'pro-life Democrat'?





Fear mounts in Austin as serial bomber uses tripwire
China's Xi strikes nationalistic tone in parliament address
Scandal-hit Weinstein Co. files for bankruptcy protection
Self-driving vehicle strikes and kills pedestrian in Arizona
Austin likely facing 'serial bomber,' police chief says
Supreme Court upholds Arizona licenses for illegals
Supreme Court keeps revised Pa. congressional map in place


'You run the damn Justice Department': Holder says Sessions must 'have the guts' to say no to Trump
Sanhedrin invites Arabs to join 3rd Temple project
Florida massacre suspect’s brother charged with trespassing – at same school of killings
The final solution for Farrakahn
Uproar after New Jersey high school allegedly suspends students over gun-range photo


Cartoon of the Day


Corporate taxes get the think tank treatment

Cargo ships at seaWhile lawmakers are debating tax reform, think tanks are also offering their own opinions about one ongoing debate: corporate taxes.