Arm twisting Amazon: More states to collect sales taxes

Tuesday, January 31, 2017
Chris Woodward (

online shopping cartStarting Wednesday (Feb. 1), Amazon customers in many states will begin paying sales taxes – but is the massive web-based retailer being bullied into collecting taxes? At least one observer thinks that's the case.

Tax collection begins tomorrow in Mississippi, Missouri, Rhode Island, South Dakota, and Vermont. It already started this month in Louisiana, Iowa, Nebraska, and Utah; and begins in Wyoming on March 1.

According to The Associated Press, many online U.S. shoppers have for years paid sales taxes whenever they bought goods from Amazon, but the company dragged its feet on collecting sales taxes in small and low-populated states where it has no distribution centers or corporate offices. An online publisher argues Amazon has been given little choice in the matter.

"Essentially Amazon is being bullied by the threat of additional regulatory burdens into collecting sales taxes for additional states," responds Ari Armstrong, publisher of Freedom Outlook.

"For example, Associated Press reports that Rhode Island was considering legislation similar to Colorado's so-called Amazon tax, which in effect forced or tried to force Amazon to comply with paperwork requirements basically making them serve as tax enforcers or else collect the sales tax themselves."

What about Amazon dragging its feet on collecting sales taxes in some states?


"According to now old court rulings, it's been the case for many years that if an online retailer has an in-state physical presence, then they have to go ahead and collect sales tax," answers Armstrong. "So for example, Barnes & Noble – if they have physical stores in your state [and] if they ship ... out of that state, they have to collect sales tax from the state where they have physical presence."

Armstrong explains that the same applies to Amazon where it has distribution centers.

"So for example, they're now opening new centers here in Colorado, which gives them a physical presence," he continues. "So ironically, the Colorado statutes aren't even at play in Colorado anymore because of the physical presence requirement. But those statutes are now forming a model for other states where there is no physical nexus for those states to essentially compel Amazon to collect sales tax."

Armstrong admits Amazon is set up to a large degree now to collect sales taxes; so the issue, he believes, is what this does to Amazon's competitors.

"There is a way in which this is actually good for Amazon, even though on net it's bad insofar as it puts Amazon's competitors who are not so equipped to comply with these paperwork and sales tax burdens," he explains.

"In a way it sort of sets Amazon to be even more a major player in terms of state-to-state sales. But nevertheless, I think whether you're talking about Amazon or other retailers, my personal view is that it's essentially unjust for state governments to seek to regulate businesses out of their states – and that's essentially what's going on here with basically making online retailers enforcements for state-level sales tax enforcements."


We moderate all reader comments, usually within 24 hours of posting (longer on weekends). Please limit your comment to 300 words or less and ensure it addresses the article - NOT another reader's comments. Comments that contain a link (URL), an inordinate number of words in ALL CAPS, rude remarks directed at other readers, or profanity/vulgarity will not be approved. More details




The best word to describe the non-stop flow of pro-LGBT messaging is…





Cuomo: 'Embarrassed' by allegations, but will not resign
GOP takes aim at Biden's health care pick on abortion rights
SUV in deadly California crash came through border fence
Majority of small businesses not requiring vaccines, tests
Weeks after storms, water crisis continues in Mississippi


Amazon: First they dropped Bibles, then they dropped books
Covid death data fraud
The woke attack on mathematics has created 'white math'
Ridiculous: How Dr. Seuss Enterprises caved to the outrageous shrieks of the woke mob
Tucker Carlson: Lockdowns are killing our children, and everyone knows it -- including teachers' unions


Cartoon of the Day
With pipelines under way, are oil companies still in?

TransCanada Keystone XLThe Keystone XL and Dakota Access pipelines may actually see completion thanks to the Trump administration, but it remains to be seen if companies are even still interested.