VA considers healthcare mandate unconstitutional
Jim Brown - OneNewsNow - 3/9/2010 7:00:00 AMBookmark and Share

VirginiaVirginia is poised to pass a law that says residents cannot be compelled to purchase health insurance they don't want.

 

A bill that has been passed by Virginia's Senate and House of Delegates is designed to challenge President Obama's national healthcare reform plan. It states that mandates should not be imposed on people for health insurance.

Bob Marshall (VA Delegate)The chief sponsor of the measure, Delegate Bob Marshall, notes that Congress has never required individuals or businesses to directly purchase any good or service, and he believes it is unconstitutional to force every legal resident of the U.S. to purchase health insurance.

"They're not doing this after they examine the Constitution and history.  They're reaching this conclusion because they need that to happen to fund their program," Marshall contends. "So this is a way of proceeding completely backwards.  The idea here is you're doing nothing, but they're going to have to hold that that constitutes economic activity that substantially affects interstate commerce.  That's like saying, 'Because I'm not giving my kidney to someone who needs a kidney, I am personally causing them to have ill health or maybe even die.'  This is bizarre reasoning."

According to the state lawmaker, President Obama is trying to "shift from a government by social compact to a government where the leaders tell the subjects what to do."  Marshall adds that "it's no wonder Obama has so many czars running around DC because he's acting like a Russian czar before the Russian revolution."

 

iTunes Podcast

 




  (average 0 out of 5)
View Comments



If you believe OneNewsNow.com is an important source for Christian news,
please consider a
 
small tax-deductible gift for this service. 





9/6/2010 5:03:20 AM